West Point NY. 28. Oct: 1852.
My dear Colonel.
I have delayed replying to your letter of the 20th in the hope of being able to say something satisfactory in the case of your nephew. I can well understand the reluctance of his parents to withdraw him from the Academy, & can sympathize with them & him on the occasion. His case is a painful one, & that you may understand the footing upon which he remains, I enclose for your perusal, a copy of the report of the Medical board upon his admission. I referred the application of his father for a sick leave to Dr. C. who reports that he cannot recommend a leave, as his disease is an insuperable objection to his remaining at the Academy. He is not under treatment at this time, but in the performance of his duty, & I know of no better course, than to let him try what he can do, if you do not think it injurious. His Professors do not report favorably of his progress, and you may be assured that he shall receive every attention while here that his situation calls for.
Very truly Yours
(Signed) R. E.Lee
Superintendent's Daily Correspondence United States Military Academy
Superintendent's Letter Book No. 2, p. 296. Addressed “Col.: Smith Washington D.C.”